After seeing several pups and their parents today I decided against a German Shepard. Several King Shepards in the area and those are just too big (fine for me but got a "wtf!?" when my gf saw the mother and I explained the father was even bigger, I want her to be comfortable with the full grown version and not just the cute puppy size) and shed far too much for keeping in the house, with additional hip/joint issues down the road.
I found some regular German Shepherd pups with a mom that had a very sweet, labrador level, temperament. However, even with the mom being freshly bathed and obviously taken care of the shedding was too much for me.
I decided against the Belgian Malinois since my gf has little experience with aggressive/high maintenance/high energy working dogs. I figured I would go with something a bit more manageable for her and, more importantly, my sanity.
After some research I decided to go with a husky. Shedding still an issue but it seems this breed does so seasonally...or maybe not since the season doesn't really change much here. I guess I'll find out. I was also concerned with the heat here being a bit much for the breed but it appears they adapt to warmer climates and have little issue as long as you take some basic precautions.
It has only been half a day but I'm quite happy with this pup. It has a playful but gentle temperament and when the tv comes on it sits and watched quietly.
Pets & Animals Best Posts in Thread: German Shepherd - Belgian Malinois Pups
Page 1 of 2
-
Attached Files:
- Like x 10
-
-
We have too Maligators, the youngest of which came from Shawn I think (my wife got him while I was crawling around the wilds of another country). They're great dogs..... Hardworking, fun, playful and VERY protective. Never had a problem with shedding either and don't ever get trick or treaters, carol singers or hawkers.
Observing mode:
Then playful mode:
Attached Files:
- Like x 6
- Agree x 1
-
-
ShawnM Living the dream, Plan B ★ No Ads ★ Highly Rated Poster Showcase Reviewer Blood Donor Veteran Air Force
- Messages:
- 1,523
- Trophy Points:
- 371
- Occupation:
- Senior Construction Manager
- Location:
- Okinawa/Tanjay
- Ratings:
- +1,778 / 219
- Blood Type:
- A-
I agree there are few "bad" dogs, but unfortunately too many bad owners.
I am a huge fan of Belgian Malinois and have posted many times about their attributes and why we love ours so much. With that said, they are a demanding breed that needs exercise and time with their family; we would never allow one to go to a first time dog owner. Both our girls had 2 litters so they are "retired" from breeding. Our big boy is still up for stud though.
Huskies are interesting...we have one and unfortunately lost one a couple years ago to an open gate. I personally find them aloof and for the first year or so remind me of a cat in their attitude. After that they are really sweet and are a pleasure to listen to as they try to "talk" to you.
Much respect always for responsible pet owners!
Shawn- Like x 4
- Agree x 2
Last edited: Jan 6, 2021 -
ShawnM Living the dream, Plan B ★ No Ads ★ Highly Rated Poster Showcase Reviewer Blood Donor Veteran Air Force
- Messages:
- 1,523
- Trophy Points:
- 371
- Occupation:
- Senior Construction Manager
- Location:
- Okinawa/Tanjay
- Ratings:
- +1,778 / 219
- Blood Type:
- A-
Shedding is pretty much year round, I haven't noticed the twice a year heavy shed that some of our other dogs go through.
Best of luck with your new pup!
Shawn- Like x 3
- Thanks x 1
-
Liverpool fan DI Senior Member Showcase Reviewer
I don't know how much knowledge you have about dog breeds, but my guess is you gain the info you need and maybe already have some experience with this kind of dog from the army. Many people don't know there are working dogs and show dogs, the difference is like night and day. The words working and show dog says it all. These dogs are bred for different purposes, for the show dog is the appearance most important, and their working skills are no longer present at all in most of these dogs. My friend has just bought a female puppy for 20 k, Belgian Malinois, he wants a male but the dog breeder told him all males were reserved for the police. I train German and Belgian shepherd in many years, obedience, tracks, and defense work. In the Philippines, defense work are only allowed for people who work in the army or police
- Informative x 3
- Winner x 1
-
ShawnM Living the dream, Plan B ★ No Ads ★ Highly Rated Poster Showcase Reviewer Blood Donor Veteran Air Force
- Messages:
- 1,523
- Trophy Points:
- 371
- Occupation:
- Senior Construction Manager
- Location:
- Okinawa/Tanjay
- Ratings:
- +1,778 / 219
- Blood Type:
- A-
I agree that the local dogs can be great dogs if treated/raised properly. We've had a number over the years that were mostly rescues and were rehomed. One of the best dogs we have is a little mixed breed runt we were able to adopt from a lumber yard.
It is really about what you are looking for in a dog. A Belgian Malinois is great at both being a family dog as well as fiercely protective of their family and make excellent watch dogs. Our Husky is sweet with a very unique personality but would never qualify to be a watch dog as she loves anyone that will either pet her or feed her. Our Papillon is a great companion, energetic and will let you know if he hears something...but not the most intimidating dog breed out there.
Shawn- Agree x 2
- Like x 1
Last edited: Jan 9, 2021 -
- Informative x 3
-
- Like x 3
-
- Like x 1
- Agree x 1
-
- Like x 1
- Agree x 1
Page 1 of 2