I went out and had a look at the bridge and think the fault lies with the cement supplier.
Attached are a couple of pictures. They show that the concrete literally turned into small pieces and "dust".
There was a lot of re-bar. The top cord seemed to have a lot. The bottom cord was not visible so who knows.
The bridge is arched slightly about 8-12" over a 60' span which looks about right IMO. The concrete would be in bulk modulus (compression mode) and should no have failed.
![]()
![]()
I met an Aussie that makes concrete paving stones for driveways and sidewalks. He got a batch of bad cement and his paving stones literally crumbled in his hands. The cement was manufactured on Cebu island. The factory actually replaced his 250 bags of bad cement and gave him another 250 bags to make up for his troubles. The cement factory said they only had 500 bags of the bad batch. Maybe there was more defective product and some of it may have ended up here.
At least the bridge failed before it was completed and people were using it.
Welcome!
By registering with us, you'll be able to discuss, share and private message with other members of our community.
Best Posts in Thread: New caunduay bridge collapses
Page 1 of 2
-
-
Dave_Hounddriver DI Forum Luminary Highly Rated Poster
-
Agree x 2
-
Informative x 2
-
-
ChMacQueen DI Forum Patron Highly Rated Poster Showcase Reviewer Veteran Army
I wonder if they will be required to pay back the money already paid for the construction so they can find a new construction company or at least make them rebuild it again from scratch off their own money. I'm betting though that they will just walk away saying the cash was already spent and its not their fault. After all the local politicians who got their cut aren't going to cough it back up or risk being ratted out if they hold the company accountable.
-
Agree x 4
-
-
Here is some more info about the area being opened for the road to proceed.
Oscar and Rosario Yutangco-Torres family donated the years-long unresolved obstacle in the south diversion road in Junob that paved and cleared the way for a four-lane highway from Bacong to Sibulan. The Mangacop family also gave way of their fence to let the City diversion road pass. Thanks to the families said Councilors Lani Ramon, Michael Bandal, Jose Kenneth Arbas and Karissa Tolentino who witnessed the demolitions led by Mayor Felipe Remollo who took only two weeks to clear the way “with gentle persuasion.”
-
Like x 2
-
Informative x 1
-
-
-
Informative x 2
-
Agree x 1
-
-
Why don't they just put up a Bailey Bridge. There are lots of them all over the world and many have been there since the second world war. Most of the concrete bridge here appear to need repairing after a very few years. You often see them removing the concrete from around the rebar, which indicates to me that the original concrete was sub standard. If you were sarcastic you might think this is deliberate, otherwise a regular source of income for the politicos might disappear.
-
Agree x 2
-
Informative x 1
-
-
He's already lost face in front of UyCondev and the general public, I reckon you're right. Hopefully, their houses are better constructed than their bridges.
-
Agree x 2
-
Like x 1
-
-
There are some interesting comments on the face book hukad page as to why it failed.
One comment mentioned some sort of tensioners had given away and the concrete had failed and this was why it was taking so long to finish.
This company seems to have most of the construction jobs on Negros so I should image their truck mixers are a bit stretched to cover all the jobs.-
Agree x 2
-
Like x 1
-
-
-
Agree x 3
-
Funny x 1
-
-
Just goes to show building a house and a bridge aren't necessarily the same thing. Better it failed before it was completed, instead of after it was completed. I wonder whose palms got greased on this one.
-
Like x 2
-
Agree x 1
-
Page 1 of 2