I tend to agree with Notmyrealname on this. A Moderator has a fine line to follow and must be impartial in making decisions such as this and that quoted reply, in my opinion, falls short of what is expected. I also wonder who is responsible to who? If there is more than one Moderator? It is clear here that is the case! Who has control of the Moderators? Is there a senior Moderator who can moderate the moderators?